Online
edition of India's National Newspaper Monday, Jun 30, 2003
The new concept of producer companies
TILL RECENTLY, the Companies Act, 1956 (the Act), recognised only three
types of companies, namely,companies limited by shares (sub-divided into public
limited and private limited companies), companies limited by guarantees and
unlimited companies. With the coming into force on February 6 of the Companies
(Amendment) Act 2002, (1 of 2003), a fourth category, `producer companies,'
finds a place in the Act.
For this, a new Part IXA, divided into
12 chapters, has been included in the Act, comprising 46 sections, interestingly
numbered as 581A to 581Z and 581ZA to 581ZT. However, the section that defines
the various types of companies that can be incorporated under the Act remains
unaltered.
The new concept of producer companies is based on the
recommendations of an expert committee led by noted economist, Y. K. Alagh. The
committee was asked (a) to frame a legislation that would enable incorporation
of cooperatives as companies and conversion of existing cooperatives into
companies and (b) to ensure that the proposed legislation accommodated the
unique elements of cooperative business with a regulatory framework similar to
that of companies.
The new type is termed as `producer company',
to indicate that only certain categories of persons can participate in the
ownership of such companies. The members have necessarily to be `primary
producers,' that is, persons engaged in an activity connected with, or related
to, primary produce.
What is primary produce? In terms of the Act
it is a produce of farmers arising from agriculture including animal husbandry,
horticulture, floriculture, pisciculture, viticulture, forestry, forest
products, re-vegetation, bee raising and farming plantation products: produce of
persons engaged in handloom, handicraft and other cottage industries: by -
products of such products; and products arising out of ancillary
industries.
The 46 new sections respectively deal with
incorporation of producer companies: their management; general meetings; share
capital and members rights; finance, accounts and audit; loan to members and
investments; penalties; amalgamation, merger or division; resolution of
disputes; and reconversion of producer company to inter-State cooperative
society. A few salient features are now briefly described.
Formation Any ten
or more individuals, each of them being a producer, that is, any person engaged
in any activity connected with primary produce, any two or more producer
institutions, that is, producer companies or any other institution having only
producers or producer companies as its members or a combination of ten or more
individuals and producer institutions, can get a producer company incorporated
under the Act.
The companies shall be termed as limited and the
liability of the members will be limited to the amount, if any, unpaid on the
shares. On registration, the producer company shall become as if it is a private
limited company with the significant difference that a minimum of two persons
cannot get them registered, the provision relating to a minimum paid-up capital
of Rs. 1 lakh will not apply and the maximum number of members can also exceed
50.
Members' equity cannot be publicly traded but be only
transferred. As such, "producer companies would not be vulnerable to takeover by
other companies or by MNCs.''
Objects The
objects of producer companies shall include one or more of the eleven items
specified in the Act, the more important being:
(i) Production,
harvesting, procurement, grading, pooling, handling, marketing, selling, export
of primary produce of members or import of goods or services for their
benefit;
(ii) Processing including preserving, drying, distilling,
brewing, venting, canning and packaging of produce of its members; and
(iii) Manufacture, sale or supply of machinery, equipment or consumables mainly
to its members.
The other objects include rendering technical or
consultancy services, insurance, generation, transmission and distribution of
power and revitalisation of land and water resources; promoting techniques of
mutuality and mutual assistance; welfare measures and providing education on
mutual assistance principles.
It is to be noted that private limited
or public limited companies are not hamstrung by such restrictions as to their
objectives, provided they are legal.
Management (a)
Every producer company is to have at least five and not more than 15 directors.
Minimum prescribed for private limited is two and for public limited three,
while the maximum will depend on the number mentioned in the respective
Articles. Usually the maximum is pegged at twelve.
(b) A full time
chief executive, by whatever name called, is to be appointed by the board. He
shall be an ex-officio director and will not be liable to retire by rotation. He
shall be entrusted with substantial powers of management as the board may
determine. This provision differs from that applicable to limited companies — a
private limited need not have any chief executive while public limited
companies, only with paidup capital exceeding Rs. 5 crores, have to have a
managing director.
(c) A stipulation that could dismay company
secretaries is that only producer companies having an average annual turnover
exceeding Rs. 5 crores in each of three consecutive years need have a whole-time
secretary. It is not mentioned what would happen to the incumbent, if the
turnover falls below this minimum. This is in contrast to the mandate that
private and public limited companies having a paid-up capital of Rs. 2 crores or
more should have a whole-time secretary.
Members'
benefits Members will initially receive only such value
for the produce or products pooled and supplied as the directors may determine.
The withheld amount may be disbursed later either in cash or in kind or by
allotment of equity shares.
Members will be eligible to receive
bonus shares.
An interesting provision is for the distribution of
patronage bonus (akin to dividend) after the annual accounts are approved —
patronage bonus means payment out of surplus income to members in proportion to
their respective patronage (not shareholding). Patronage, in turn, is defined as
the use of services offered by producer companies to their members by
participation in their business activities. Incidentally, there is an error in
drafting — the powers of the board include "determination of the dividend
payable'' — it should have been "patronage bonus payable.''
Reserves
Every producer company has to maintain a general reserve in every financial year
and in case there is not sufficient funds in any year for such transfer, the
shortfall has to be made up by members' contribution in proportion to their
patronage in the business This is a well-thought out provision.
Audit An
unnecessary stipulation is that "without prejudice to the concerned sections in
the Act,'' the auditors of producer companies have to specially report on some
additional items such as debts due and bad debts, verification of cash balances
and securities, details of assets and liabilities, loans extended to directors
and details of donations and subscriptions. These are all integral parts of any
audit, both statutory and internal and one fails to understand the logic behind
this stipulation.
Internal
audit It is mandated that every producer company should
carry out internal audit of its accounts by chartered accountants. The Act has
not so far made it compulsory for limited companies to carry out internal audit,
although listed companies, by virtue of the clause in the listing agreement
relating to corporate governance, are to have a full-scale internal audit
system.
Resolution of
disputes Any dispute relating to the formation,
management or business of producers companies is to be settled by conciliation
or by arbitration under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as if the
parties to the dispute have consented in writing to such procedure. The
arbitrator's decision shall be final. This seems to be inequitable since usually
an arbitration award can be appealed against in high courts.
Inter-State cooperative societies
With objects not confined to one State may make an
application to the Registrar for recognition as producer companies. The statute
also provides for reconversion of such producer companies to their former status
as inter- State cooperative societies subject to the approval of High Court. In
conclusion, it is to be noted that "all the limitations, restrictions and
provision of the Act, other than those specified in Part IXA, applicable to a
private limited company, shall, as far as may be, apply to a producer company,
as if it is a private limited company under the Act in so far as they are not in
conflict with the provisions of this Part.'' In other words, a producer company
is a hybrid between a private limited company and a cooperative society.
S.
Balakrishnan